Judging Criteria
AmeriStar judges will score each criteria listed within each section below on a scale of 1-5. 5= strongly agree, 1=strongly disagree.
Category
|
Criteria
|
Beverages, Alcoholic
Beverages, Non Alcoholic
Cosmetics
Drug & Pharmaceutical
Electronics
Food, Frozen
Food, Refrigerated
Food, Shelf Stable
Health & Beauty Aids
Household Products
Industrial /Commercial
Medical Device
Promotional / Display
Other
|
Economics
- The package addresses a specific economic concern.
- The package design results in cost savings. Cost savings may be demonstrated by any or all of the following:
- Distribution Improvements
- Damage Reduction
- Packing/Processing Efficiencies
- Machinability
- Material Standardization
- Labor Costs
- Warehousing/Storage costs
- Material Costs
- This design addresses the package’s life cycle, as demonstrated by any/all of the following:
- Reusability
- Recyclability
- Material Reduction
- Improved Material Strength
- Density Improvements
Environmental Impact
- The package successfully addresses current and appropriate environmental concerns.
- The package design has eliminated, avoided or reduced unnecessary materials.
- Design consideration includes reusable and/or recyclable materials/systems where available.
- The package uses recycled materials where possible.
- The design has considered end-of-life scenarios for the package.
- The design minimizes the potential negative effects the package and its components will have on the environment.
- The design has undergone a life cycle review.
Innovation
- The package demonstrates an application of a “new idea.”
- The package demonstrates a creative use of existing ideas.
- The package makes use of new design, material or technique.
- The design successfully transfers packaging principles from other industries.
- The package reflects important new marketing strategies.
- The package reflects new manufacturing advances.
Marketing
- The structural design contributes to product image or shelf impact.
- The package design improves or contributes to acceptance of the product.
- The package’s marketing appeal has been significantly improved by the redesign
Package Performance
- The package is easily filled, opened, dispensed, reclosed, stored.
- It can be run on existing packaging machinery.
- It is easily integrated into the existing distribution system.
- The package offers significant new benefits in handling, storage and warehousing.
Product Protection
- The package successfully protects the biological, chemical and/or physical integrity of the product.
- The original product protection requirements, as specified, are sufficiently addressed by this package design.
- The testing specified sufficiently addresses the need for protection for this application.
- The package successfully meets the test requirements expressed (evidence shown).
|
Category
|
Criteria
|
Design Excellence |
Innovation
- The package demonstrates an application of a “new idea”.
- The package demonstrates a creative use of existing ideas.
- The package makes use of new design, material or technique.
- The design successfully transfers packaging principles from other industries.
- The package reflects important new marketing strategies.
- The package reflects new manufacturing advances.
Product Protection
- The package successfully protects the biological, chemical and/or physical integrity of the product.
- The original product protection requirements, as specified, are sufficiently addressed by this package design.
- The testing specified sufficiently addresses the need for protection for this application.
- The package successfully meets the test requirements expressed (evidence shown)
Package Design
- The package structure and package design are integrated to coordinate the product’s value
- The package improves the functionality of the product
- The package persuades consumers to think about the product/category in a new way
- The package showcases the product’s design benefit
- The package improves the findability of the product on shelf (is this enhanced merchandising?)
- The package motivates consumers to purchase
- The package improves the user experience (could be in both the supply chain and consumers)
- The package effectively uses materials to support the circular economy
|
Category
|
Criteria
|
Packaging that Saves Food: Agriculture/
Food Service
/Retail (Primary Packaging)
|
Innovation
- The package demonstrates an application of a “new idea.”
- The package demonstrates a creative use of existing ideas.
- The package makes use of new design, material or technique.
- The design successfully transfers packaging principles from other industries.
- The package reflects important new marketing strategies.
- The package reflects new manufacturing advances.
Product Protection
- The package successfully protects the biological, chemical and/or physical integrity of the product.
- The original product protection requirements, as specified, are sufficiently addressed by this package design.
- The testing specified sufficiently addresses the need for protection for this application.
- The package successfully meets the test requirements expressed (evidence shown)
Saves Food
- The package minimizes food loss?
- The package minimizes food waste?
- The package extends the product’s shelf life?
- The package improves the supply chain for food?
- The package enhances distribution efficiency
|
Category
|
Criteria
|
Sustainable Packaging |
Innovation
- The package demonstrates an application of a “new idea”.
- The package demonstrates a creative use of existing ideas.
- The package makes use of new design, material or technique.
- The design successfully transfers packaging principles from other industries.
- The package reflects important new marketing strategies.
- The package reflects new manufacturing advances.
Product Protection
- The package successfully protects the biological, chemical and/or physical integrity of the product.
- The original product protection requirements, as specified, are sufficiently addressed by this package design.
- The testing specified sufficiently addresses the need for protection for this application.
- The package successfully meets the test requirements expressed (evidence shown).
Sustainability
- The package successfully addresses current and appropriate environmental concerns.
- The package design has eliminated, avoided or reduced unnecessary materials.
- Design consideration includes reusable and/or recyclable materials/systems where available.
- The package uses recycled, compostable, or biodegradable materials where possible.
- The design has considered end-of-life or circular economy scenarios for the package.
- The design minimizes the potential negative effects the package and its components will have on the environment.
- The design has undergone a life cycle review.
|
|
For questions regarding your AmeriStar entry, please email us at info@iopp.org.